Skip to content

APPG on the Great Lakes Region of Africa

  • Increase font size
  • Decrease font size
  • Default font size
Michela Wrong: Africa - Why hoping for the best brings the worst PDF Print E-mail
Written by APPG Administrator   
Friday, 06 October 2006 16:58

Monday 9th October 2006  Congo's been bleeding to death for five centuries," John le Carré has a character declare in his new Africa novel, The Mission Song. "Fucked by the Arab slavers, fucked by their fellow Africans, fucked by the United Nations, the CIA, the Christians, the Belgians, the French, the Brits, the Rwandans, the diamond companies, the gold companies, the mineral companies, half the world's carpetbaggers, their own government in Kinshasa, and any minute now they're going to be fucked by the oil companies. Time they had a break . . ."

Time they had a break, indeed. But as the second round of presidential elections approaches in the Democratic Republic of Congo, it strikes me that le Carré could have added yet one more candidate to his magnificent roll-call of those who have royally screwed the former Zaire: the naive souls who believe in democracy's capacity to heal all wounds.

On 29 October, the DRC goes to the polls in a run-off between President Joseph Kabila and his nearest rival, Jean-Pierre Bemba. The first round was by no means glitch-free, but the foreign donors who spent $420m organising a vote across a country where tarmacked roads are often only a memory none the less pulled off a logistical miracle.

As Peter Cook told the one-legged actor auditioning for the role of Tarzan: "I've got nothing against your right leg. Trouble is, neither have you." Like him, I've got nothing against the international community's role in staging the Congolese elections - but there is simply not enough to stand against that achievement. And the absence of that second limb risks en suring that the $420m, like the billions more that are spent keeping the world's biggest UN peacekeeping force in situ, ends up as money down the drain.

After six years of a civil war that neither the government nor the various rebel groups in the DRC proved capable of winning, it made sense to get the parties around a table. At Sun City in South Africa, the Kinshasa government agreed with rebel warlords to set up a transitional administration, organise elections and let Congo's citizens decide who should run the place. It would be the first time in four decades, after all, anyone had bothered to ask their opinion.

A laudable principle. So why are residents, diplomats and UN officials in Kinshasa "scared witless", as a veteran Congo watcher told me?

This is not hysteria; the ingredients for serious trouble are all in place. A new form of xeno phobia between Lingala-speaking westerners, who regard themselves as "sons of the soil", and Swahili-speaking easterners, rejected as "foreigners", is being stoked by television stations owned by the two candidates. Unpaid soldiers, whose wages are routinely pocketed by their commanders, roam at will. Both men control private armies that opened fire on each other after the first round of voting, leaving 30 dead, and have been importing weapons ahead of the coming showdown.

Whoever loses is certain to denounce the results as rigged. Both Kabila and Bemba, after all, are men who owe their prominence to their readiness to take up arms, so why accept the verdict of the polls? At best, analysts say, there may be a few days of rioting. At worst, we could see pitched battles between Kabila's and Bemba's men, with the youth of Kinshasa joining in on Bemba's side and the violence rippling out to the DRC's provinces, always vulnerable to the siren call of secession.

That so much money and so many good intentions have produced such an alarming mise en scène highlights the weaknesses to which the international community falls prey when chairing peace talks in Africa. The first failing is the tendency, in the impatience to clinch a deal, to gloss over a crucial detail, brushing away warnings in the hope that as a settlement takes hold it will gradually prove irrelevant. Time and again, the opposite occurs: the "detail" grows in importance, eventually destroying all the fine work done around it.

In this case, the detail was the security arrangements hammered out between Kabila and the rebel factions as a precondition for the rebels' move to Kinshasa. After much dispute, the issue was left in limbo. As a result, a city of nearly seven million, miraculously spared serious fighting until now, could well be the scene of a bloody Bemba-Kabila showdown.

The second failing is a preference for sweep-ing acts of media-friendly symbolism over the sort of pains taking technical work that doesn't lend itself to glib headlines. Under Mobutu Sese Seko, Congo became a husk of a state. As its institutions of government were stripped of power, daily life became dominated by the appetites of thousands of out-of-control young men wandering around with guns. Conscious of this, experts have repeatedly urged western donors to dedicate more funds to the integration, training and demobilisation of the DRC's armed forces.

The donors mouthed the right words, but squabbled over who should take the lead. It was so much easier to focus on elections, which didn't involve the tricky sovereignty issues raised by the restructuring of an African army. And, given the glowing accounts the world's press delivered after the first round, it was so much more rewarding.

If all hell breaks loose in the DRC after 29 October - and I desperately hope it does not - it will be tragic evidence of the damage a very human inclination to hope for the best can do.
 

Women's Voices

womens_voices-0001-module

Regional News Feeds

  • Analysis: The LRA - not yet a spent force
    JOHANNESBURG 03 February 2012 (IRIN) - The belief that the end is nigh for Joseph Kony’s Lord’s Resistance Army (LRA) - a small but ruthless transnational armed group operating in four African states - underestimates its resilience and overestimates the unity and capability of the forces ranged against it, say analysts.
  • DRC: Alarm bells over poor funding for HIV treatment
    NAIROBI/KINSHASA 02 February 2012 (IRIN) - The lives of thousands of HIV-positive people in the Democratic Republic of Congo are at risk as the country faces declining donor funding and a severe shortage of HIV treatment, according to Médecins Sans Frontières.
  • BURUNDI: Fears of looming food shortage
    BUJUMBURA 27 January 2012 (IRIN) - There are fears of a looming food shortage in Burundi after heavy rains damaged two successive harvests, say officials.
  • BURUNDI: Fears of looming food shortage
    BUJUMBURA 27 January 2012 (IRIN) - There are fears of a looming food shortage in Burundi after heavy rains damaged two successive harvests, say officials.
  • FILM: Our most-watched films of 2011
    NAIROBI 28 December 2011 (IRIN) - Launched in 2004, IRIN’s film unit has won numerous awards for its productions, several of which have been aired by prominent international broadcasters. Here is a list of the unit’s most-watched films in 2011.
  • CLIMATE CHANGE: Durban or bust - the Trans-African Caravan of Hope
    KAMPALA 02 December 2011 (IRIN) - Brandishing a plea for developed countries to make good their promises to reduce carbon emissions, 300 farmers, youths and activists took the scenic route to the COP17 conference in Durban, travelling more than 7,000km from Burundi in 17 days, through 10 eastern and southern African countries, aboard a convoy of buses draped in various national flags.
  • Analysis: The LRA - not yet a spent force
    JOHANNESBURG 03 February 2012 (IRIN) - The belief that the end is nigh for Joseph Kony’s Lord’s Resistance Army (LRA) - a small but ruthless transnational armed group operating in four African states - underestimates its resilience and overestimates the unity and capability of the forces ranged against it, say analysts.
  • DRC: Alarm bells over poor funding for HIV treatment
    NAIROBI/KINSHASA 02 February 2012 (IRIN) - The lives of thousands of HIV-positive people in the Democratic Republic of Congo are at risk as the country faces declining donor funding and a severe shortage of HIV treatment, according to Médecins Sans Frontières.
  • AFRICA: High cost of child trafficking
    POINTE NOIRE 25 January 2012 (IRIN) - Forced child labour remains rampant in Central Africa, where poverty fuels the trafficking of children from poorer countries to oil-rich states such as Gabon, Equatorial Guinea and the Republic of Congo, according to experts.
  • HEALTH: The true burden of cancer
    LONDON 26 January 2012 (IRIN) - Breast cancer continues to be misunderstood, under-diagnosed and fatal, particularly in developing countries, say researchers, despite more than one million official annual diagnoses and almost half a million recorded deaths annually.
  • RWANDA: Aiming towards two million medical male circumcisions
    KIGALI 09 January 2012 (IRIN) - This will be a busy year for Rwanda's health centres as the country attempts to reach its goal of medically circumcising 50 percent of men by June 2013 as part of HIV prevention efforts.
  • CLIMATE CHANGE: Durban or bust - the Trans-African Caravan of Hope
    KAMPALA 02 December 2011 (IRIN) - Brandishing a plea for developed countries to make good their promises to reduce carbon emissions, 300 farmers, youths and activists took the scenic route to the COP17 conference in Durban, travelling more than 7,000km from Burundi in 17 days, through 10 eastern and southern African countries, aboard a convoy of buses draped in various national flags.
  • Analysis: The LRA - not yet a spent force
    JOHANNESBURG 03 February 2012 (IRIN) - The belief that the end is nigh for Joseph Kony’s Lord’s Resistance Army (LRA) - a small but ruthless transnational armed group operating in four African states - underestimates its resilience and overestimates the unity and capability of the forces ranged against it, say analysts.
  • SOUTH SUDAN-UGANDA: Economic migrants battle xenophobia
    JUBA/KAMPALA 30 January 2012 (IRIN) - Petty traders from Uganda, South Sudan's largest trading partner, crowd into Konyo Konyo market in Juba selling used clothes, vegetables and household wares. Lacking economic prospects at home, they come in the hope of finding better opportunities in Juba's booming post-war economy.
  • UGANDA: Basua community battles for survival
    BUNDIMASOLI 26 January 2012 (IRIN) - The marginalized western Ugandan Basua community is fighting extinction; forcibly removed from their forest home two decades ago, they have struggled to cope with modern life and have been ravaged by health crises, including HIV.
  • KENYA: Clashes highlight dangers of devolution
    ISIOLO, 3 February 2012 (IRIN) - Politically motivated violence in the northern Kenyan town of Moyale, which has left dozens dead and tens of thousands displaced in recent weeks, shows little sign of abating and there are fears that the clashes could continue until elections are held for new local government positions.
  • NIGERIA: Never so divided, never so united
    LAGOS, 3 February 2012 (IRIN) - A month after an angry public launched protests across Nigeria over skyrocketing fuel prices due to the removal of a government subsidy, a measure of calm has returned and people seem to have settled into accepting a compromise.
  • ZIMBABWE: Improved AIDS levy collections fill part of funding gap
    HARARE, 3 February 2012 (IRIN) - With global funding for HIV/AIDS on the decline, Zimbabwe's innovative AIDS levy - a 3 percent tax on income - has become a promising source of funding for the country, with a dramatic increase in revenue collected in the past two years.

E-mail Newsletter

Keep yourself updated with our FREE newsletters now!






Le Petit Journal